What you just did is a version of the study that first showed the pattern.
The free recall study (1966): People heard a list of 15 words, one at a time, and then wrote down as many as they could in any order. Some recalled right away, and some first spent 30 seconds counting backward.
Finding: With immediate recall, the first few words and the last few words were remembered best. After the 30-second counting task, the last few words lost their advantage and the first few kept theirs.
Primacy effect: Better memory for the first few items in a list than for the items in the middle.
Recency effect: Better memory for the last few items in a list than for the items in the middle.
The next figure shows both patterns.
Recall by Position in the List
The two ends of the list come from two different systems.
Why the Two Effects Show Two Systems
The first words were rehearsed while the list went on, so they reached long-term memory. Counting backward for 30 seconds did not remove them.
The last words were still in working memory when recall began. Counting backward for 30 seconds filled working memory with numbers, so they were gone.
A delay that erases one effect but not the other means the two effects were held in different places.
The first words got into long-term memory because they were repeated, but repeating is the weakest way to get something into long-term memory.
Practice: Primacy or Recency?
For each scenario, say whether the primacy effect or the recency effect is the more likely one, and why.
A server takes a table’s six drink orders without writing them down and brings the first two correctly.
A student walks out of a lecture and can repeat the professor’s last sentence word for word.
You meet ten people at a networking event and, the next morning, remember only the names of the first few.
A witness hears a license plate read aloud once and, asked five seconds later, gets the last three characters right.
Halfway through a long grocery list you cannot recall, you still remember the first item, milk.
Practice: Answers
Primacy. The first orders were repeated while the others came in, so they reached long-term memory.
Recency. The last sentence is still in working memory, and nothing has replaced it yet.
Primacy. A night’s delay removed whatever was in working memory, and only what reached long-term memory is left.
Recency. Five seconds is short enough for the last characters to still be in working memory.
Primacy. The first item was rehearsed the longest while the list was being read.
Poll 3
Words will appear one at a time with a yes-or-no question about each one.
Answer each question in your head.
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
WINDOW
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
phone
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
hat
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
TIME
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
garden
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
red
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
radio
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
HEART
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
fence
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
PARTY
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
STAPLE
Is it capitalized? Answer yes or no in your head.
light
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
car
He drove the ______ to work.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
envelope
He picked an ______ from the tree.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
butter
He spread the ______ on his toast.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
floor
She sat on the ______ during class.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
computer
He poured the ______ over his cereal.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
t-shirt
She used the ______ to unlock the door.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
worm
The ______ barked loudly.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
candy
The boy asked his mom for ______.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
book
He opened the ______ to read.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
mirror
She tied her ______ before running.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
kite
A white ______ floated across the sky.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
banana
He put the ______ in the piggy bank.
Does it fit the sentence? Answer yes or no in your head.
Why is it easier to remember the words you tried to fit in a sentence?
The depth of processing study (1975): People saw words one at a time and answered one question about each: whether it was in capital letters, whether it rhymed with another word, or whether it fit into a sentence. Later they were given a surprise memory test.
Finding: Words judged for sentence fit were remembered far better than words judged for rhyme, and words judged for rhyme better than words judged for capital letters. Nobody had been told to memorize anything.
Shallow Processing
Shallow processing: Paying attention to the surface features of information, such as how a word looks or sounds.
Ex: Noticing that a word is printed in capital letters.
Ex: Saying a phone number over and over until you can type it in.
Repeating something many times is shallow processing. It keeps information in working memory, but it does not by itself move it into long-term memory, at least beyond a few minutes. What does?
Deep Processing
Deep processing: Paying attention to the meaning of information and how it relates to other things you know.
Ex: Deciding whether a word makes sense in a given sentence.
Ex: Rewording one of our four core themes and coming up with your own example of it.
Deep Processing Builds Connections
Thinking about meaning creates connections between the new information and what is already in long-term memory.
Paying attention to meaning builds those paths whether or not the person is trying to remember, which is why the surprise test still showed the effect.
Every study strategy you use processes the material at one depth or the other.
Practice
For each strategy, name the depth of processing and whether the material is likely to be there in two weeks.
Rereading the chapter the night before the exam.
Writing each key term’s definition in your own words and adding an example from your own life.
Repeating a definition aloud ten times.
Making flashcards and studying them on the site every few days.
Highlighting every bolded term in the reading.
Explaining a concept to a friend who is not in the class.
Practice: Answers
Shallow (the words pass by again without being worked on), unlikely to last.
Deep (meaning and a connection to your own knowledge), likely to last.
Deep (each card asks for meaning, and you answer from memory), likely to last, and the spacing adds to it.
Shallow (which words are bold, not what they mean), unlikely to last.
Deep (you have to reword and connect it), likely to last.
Applying the Core Themes to Memory Systems
In pairs, take our four cognitive core themes. For each one, name a way it appears in what we just covered.
Applying the Core Themes to Memory Systems
Mental Representation: What gets stored is the representation you built, not the event. Deep processing changes what that representation is connected to.
Bottom-Up and Top-Down Processing: New information arrives bottom-up, and deep processing is top-down work that ties it to what you already know.
Limited Capacity: Working memory holds about four chunks, and chunking is the way around that limit.
Automatic to Controlled Processing: Repeating something runs with little effort, and deep processing is controlled work that takes attention.